|
Dad's Top
20 Revisionist Western Films - Ranked!
Countdown from #20 to #1. This
includes Dad's spoiler-free Mini-Preview!
|
|
|
Honorable
Mention |
|
 |
|
The Proposition
(2005),
Director: James L. Brooks, rated R for language,
Western violence
Three
brothers: one must live; one must die; one must decide
 Starring: Guy
Pearce, Ray Winstone, Danny Huston, John Hurt, David Wenham,
Emily Watson, Richard Wilson, Noah Taylor, Jeremy Madrona
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★☆☆
- great
"I was, in days gone
by, a believer. But, alas, I came to this beleaguered land and
the God in me
just evaporated. Let us change our toast, then, to
the God that has forgotten us."-
Jellon Lamb
Why watch this?
This uber-realistic film is stark, honest and
bare-bones wonderful.
Plot Summary:
In the harsh Australian outback of the 1880s, two outlaw
brothers are apprehended by a lawman determined to bring order
to the land. Faced with an impossible choice, the captured
outlaw must hunt down and kill his older brother, the true
leader of their gang, within nine days to save their younger
brother from hanging.
Dad's Preview:
This 1880's outback Western is brutally unromantic. There are no
heroics, no men who save the day. It's just kill or be killed
and good luck figuring out who is noble vs. devious. Everyone is
a little of both. Still, the film draws you in. So much so that
you have to see it through. I feel this is Guy Pearce's best performance on the big
screen. His portrayal of Charlie Burns is so raw and
uncomplicated. It reminded me of "the kid" from Cormac
McCarthy's likewise brutally violent book
Blood Meridian.

UK Film Council,
Surefire Films, Autonomous, Jackie O Prod.,
Pictures in
Paradise,
The Pacific Film and TV Comm., The Film
Consortium; Sony
Pictures Releasing |
|
|
|
|
#20 Top |
|
 |
|
A Fistful of Dollars
(1964),
Director: Sergio Leone, rated R for
language, Western violence
This
is the man with no name. Danger fits him like a glove.
 Starring:
Clint Eastwood, Marianne Koch, Gian Maria Volonte, Sieghardt Rupp, W. Lukschy,
Joe Edger, Antonio Prieto
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★☆☆
- great "When
a man with .45 meets a man with a rifle, you said, the man with
a pistol's a dead man. Let's see if that's true." - Joe
Why watch this? ...
it's my favorite of the Leone "Dollars" trilogy.
Plot Summary: A
wandering, nameless gunfighter arrives in a small Mexican
village caught in a brutal power struggle between two rival
smuggling families, the Rojos and the Baxters. Recognizing an
opportunity for profit, he cleverly manipulates both sides
against each other, exacerbating the conflict for personal gain.
However, as the escalating violence takes its toll, particularly
on innocent individuals, the Stranger's motivations appear to
shift, hinting at a more complex, ambiguous morality that
transcends mere financial reward.
Dad's Preview:
OK, it is a shameless rip-off of Akira Kurosawa's
Yojimbo (1961)
(BTW: Leone was sued for it and lost), but imitation is the
sincerest form of flattery, right? That said, Fistful is
a great Western. Eastwood
used these Italian films to rough up his image and that blew his
career wide open.

Jolly Film,
Constantin Film, Ocean Films; Unidis |
|
|
|
|
#19 Top |
|
 |
|
Will Penny
(1968),
Director: Tom Gries, rated Approved
The brute in
every man was also in him... And the love and the violence!
 Starring:
Charlton Heston, Joan Hackett, Donald Pleasence, Ben Johnson,
Bruce Dern, Slim Pickens, Lee Majors, Anthony Zerbe
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"Leave him be. Out here, by
hisself, no goods, winter coming on. He's gonna be a long while
dying. And all
that time, he's gonna know who done it to him.
Yes, sir, a mighty long time, and then he'll be dead." -
Preacher Quint
Why watch this?
... what happens when a loner suddenly starts to care for
others?
Plot Summary: Aging
cowboy, Will Penny, accepts a job as a line rider on a vast
ranch during a harsh winter. He discovers a stranded woman and
her son have taken refuge in his assigned cabin. Though
initially resistant, Will allows them to stay, leading to a
blossoming romance and a newfound sense of family. However, a
past confrontation with a vengeful outlaw family threatens their
fragile happiness.
Dad's Preview:
This was a very realistic Western for its time. Heston delivers
a career-defining performance as reclusive ranch hand, Will
Penny, who encounters a woman, Catherine, and her young son
living his line shack miles into the wilderness. He's torn
between duty to his employer, and the affection he develops for
the woman and son. Then a group of cutthroats show up at the
cabin. This small, intimate film intensifies when the gang takes
Will hostage and threatens to rape Catherine.

Paramount Pictures |
|
|
|
|
|
#18 Top |
|
 |
|
Bone Tomahawk
(2015),
Director: S. Craig Zahler, not rated (Bull's guess
hard
R) for Western violence, torture, language
May
the Lord have mercy and grant you a swift death.
 Starring: Kurt
Russell, Patrick Wilson, Matthew Fox, Richard Jenkins, Lili
Simmons, Evan Jonigkeit, David Arquette, Kathryn Morris
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"This is why frontier
life is so difficult. Not because of the Indians or the elements
but because of the idiots." -
Samantha
Why watch this?
This Western horror film is intense, gory, disturbing and
amazing.
Plot Summary: In the
Old West, a small-town sheriff and his unlikely posse of four
embark on a perilous journey. Their mission is to rescue three
abducted townspeople, including a sheriff's deputy, local doctor
and his daughter. The abductors are a brutal, cannibalistic clan
living in a desolate region. As they venture into dangerous
territory, they quickly realize their foe is far more savage and
ruthless than they could have imagined.
Dad's Preview:
After Tombstone,
I eagerly awaited Kurt Russell's next Western. It took a while,
then this film popped up on IMDB. I read the summation, and knew I'd love it
- sight unseen. I was not wrong. Set in the old West, ill-prepared pursuers are tracking a kidnapped girl.
They are expecting a tribe of Indians they can over-come as they
have times before. What they actually find is a blood-thirsty
cult of cannibalistic savages. This one
gets a little bloody, well actually, very, very bloody.

Caliber
Media Company, The Fyzz Facility; RLJ Entertainment |
|
|
|
|
#17 Top |
|
 |
|
Jeremiah Johnson
(1972),
Director: Sydney Pollack, rated PG
some say he's
dead... some say he never will be.
 Starring:
Robert Redford, Will Geer, Stefan Gierasch, Dell Bolton, Josh
Albee, Joaquin Martinez, Allyn Ann McLerie, Paul Benedict, Jack
Colvin, Matt Clark, Richard Angarola, Charles Tyner, Tanya
Tucker
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"And there ain't no
churches, except for this right here! And there ain't no priests
excepting the birds. By God, I are a mountain man, and I'll live
'til an arrow or a bullet finds me. And then I'll leave my bones
on this great map of the magnificent..." – Del Gue
Why watch this?
This simple, compelling Western film focuses on a lone man in
the Rocky Mountains of the mid 1800's.
Plot Summary:
Jeremiah Johnson is a veteran who seeks to escape civilization
and live a solitary life as a mountain man in the Rocky
Mountains. He faces the challenges of the harsh wilderness and
learns to survive with the help of others, eventually forming a
unique family. However, a tragic event leads to conflict with
the Crow tribe, resulting in an ongoing vendetta and Jeremiah's
transformation into a legendary figure.
Dad's Preview:
There is a realness, a raw edge, to this neo-Western. Portraying
a wild, bearded mountain man was an odd choice for the suave,
handsome Redford, but it pays off. The story is based on the life
of trapper John "Liver-Eating" Johnson. Seeing our American
wilderness, as it was back then, is awe-inspiring. That said, it
would be a dangerous, confusing, and difficult place to survive.
That is the beauty of the film. I believe this is how it would
have been. The Native Americans are portrayed honestly, with
traits both brutal and humane. People isolated in a harsh
wilderness would all have to be a little odd. That is
reality.

Sanford
Productions (III); Warner Bros. |
|
|
|
|
#16 Top |
|
 |
|
Winchester '73
(1950),
Director: Anthony Mann, rated Approved
The Gun That
Won The West!
 Starring: James
Stewart, Shelley Winters, Dan Duryea, Stephen McNally, Millard
Mitchell, Charles Drake, Will Geer, Johh McIntire, Rock Hudson
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"Yeah, he did, didn't
he? Dad said if a man had one friend, he was rich. I'm rich." -
Lin McAdam
Why watch this?
James Stewart is cinema gold, so versatile and believable.
Plot Summary: A
sharpshooter named Lin McAdam is pursuing a dangerous adversary,
Dutch Henry Brown, into Dodge City where a shooting contest is
underway with a prized, rare Winchester rifle as the grand
prize. After McAdam wins the rifle, Brown steals it, leading
McAdam on a relentless chase to retrieve both his gun and settle
their deeper, personal score.
Dad's Preview:
When Stewart signed on for the Anthony Mann Westerns, he clearly
wanted to toughen up his on-screen persona. It worked. A Western
man wanders here and there, but it is clear that he has a score
to settle against someone who wronged him in the past. This is
the first of seven Stewart-Mann collaborations, and it may be
the best. Look for a beautiful Shelly Winters as the saloon gal with
a heart.

Universal Pictures |
|
|
|
|
#15 Top |
|
 |
|
The Magnificent Seven (1960),
Director: John Sturges, rated Approved
They were
seven - And they fought like seven hundred!
 Starring: Yul
Brynner, Eli Wallach, Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson, Robert
Vaughn, Horst Buchholz, Brad Dexter, James Coburn, Jorge
Martinez de Hoyos, Vladimir Sokoloff, Rosenda Monteros, Rico Alaniz
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"Running a farm,
working like a mule every day with no guarantee anything will
ever come of it.
This is bravery."
- O'Reilly
Why watch this?
It's a real treat to see all this star-power in one film!
Plot Summary:
A poor Mexican village, repeatedly raided by bandits, sends
three villagers to seek help. They encounter Chris Adams, a
seasoned gunslinger, who advises hiring other gunmen instead of
buying weapons. Chris recruits six other skilled fighters. The
seven train the villagers to defend their homes against the
bandits' inevitable return.
Dad's Preview:
What's better than a classic Western? A classic Western with an
all-star cast. In 1960, the top new talent list started with
Brynner, McQueen, Bronson, Vaughn and Coburn. The film's showdown is very memorable, as
the seven alone stand against a horde of assaulting bandits and
their leader, the devious Mexican Calvera (played by Eli Wallach). This film was
inspired by Akira Kurosawa's masterpiece
Seven Samurai
(1954).

The Mirisch Co.,
Alpha Productions; United Artists |
|
|
|
|
#14 Top |
|
 |
|
Quigley Down Under
(1990),
Director: Simon Wincer, rated PG-13 for Western violence
The West Was
Never This Far West
 Starring: Tom
Selleck, Laura San Giacomo, Alan Rickman, Chris Haywood, Roger
Ward, Ron Haddrick, Tony Bonner, Jerome Ehlers, Ben Mendelsohn
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"Major. We already run the
misfits outta our country. We sent 'em back to England." –
Matthew Quigley
Why watch this?
Selleck fits this role like a pair of old comfortable kangaroo-skin boots.
Plot Summary:
Sharpshooter Matthew Quigley travels from America to Australia
after being hired by a wealthy rancher named Elliot Marston.
Quigley discovers Marston expects him to use his skills to
eradicate the local Aboriginal population, a task the principled
American refuses. After a clash with Marston, Quigley finds
himself stranded in the harsh Australian outback alongside a
troubled woman, and together they navigate the unforgiving
wilderness.
Dad's Preview:
Set in Australia, Quigley is a man not to be pushed around or
betrayed. When he runs afoul with a wealthy land owner, he's beaten
up and left for dead in the harsh outback, along with a slightly
crazed saloon girl. I feel this is the best of Selleck's Western
films. It's fun, beautifully shot, and "nice and dusty".
Alan Rickman is once again superb as the villain; this time a
greedy land-owner.

Pathé
Entertainment; Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer |
|
|
|
|
#13 Top |
|
 |
|
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
(1966),
Director: Sergio Leone, rated R for language and
violence
For Three Men The
Civil War Wasn't Hell. It Was Practice!
 Starring:
Clint Eastwood, Eli Wallach, Lee Van Cleef, Al Mulock, Aldo
Giuffrè, Aldo Sambrell, Benito Stafanelli, Antonio Casale, Livio
Lorenzon, Rada Rassimov, John Bartha, José Terrón, Lorenzo
Robledo, Luigi Pistilli, Mario Brega
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"You see, in this
world there's two kinds of people, my friend: Those with loaded
guns and those who dig. You dig." -
Blondie
Why watch this?
Director Sergio Leone, and Clint Eastwood, hit the jackpot with
this dirty, grimy Italian horse opera.
Plot Summary: During
the American Civil War, three men, a cool mercenary "The Good",
a greedy bandit "The Ugly", and a ruthless killer "The Bad", are
in a race to find a hidden treasure of Confederate gold. They
must navigate through the war-torn landscape, engaging in
complex alliances and betrayals as they seek the fortune. This
epic spaghetti western is renowned for its iconic characters,
captivating storyline, and legendary score.
Dad's Preview:
Yes, I know, many feel this is the best Western ever. Not me. I
do like the film, but it's not even Leone's best effort, which
is
Once Upon a Time in the West (1966). It's not even
Leone's best Eastwood film - that would be
A Fistful of
Dollars (1964). That said, this Spaghetti Western has a
ton to offer. It's got gun battles, seedy characters, even a
Civil War battle! Eastwood excels as himself, but the real
spotlight goes to the incredible Eli Wallach, a Polish Jew who
made a career playing slimy, Mexican bandits.

Produzioni Europee
Associati, United Artists |
|
|
|
|
#12 Top |
|
 |
|
Shane (1953),
Director: George Stevens, rated Approved
There never
was a man like SHANE. There never was a motion picture like
SHANE.
 Starring: Alan Ladd, Jean Arthur, Van Heflin, Brandon
deWilde, Jack Palance, Ben Johnson, Edgar Buchanan, Ellen Corby,
Emile Meyer, Elisha Cook Jr.
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"Joey, there's no living
with... with a killing. There's no going back from one. Right or
wrong, it's a brand.
A brand sticks. There's no going back." -
Shane
Why watch this?
An epic tale of the loner who tries to help a family in need.
Plot Summary:
A mysterious, soft-spoken ex-gunfighter becomes entangled in the
lives of a family of homesteaders in 1889 Wyoming. The
homesteaders, led by Joe Starrett and his family, are facing a
bitter struggle against a powerful cattle baron, Rufus Ryker,
who wants their land for his herds. Shane's presence brings a
glimmer of hope to the settlers as they fight to protect their
homes and way of life against Ryker's increasing intimidation
tactics, including the hiring of gunslinger Jack Wilson.
Dad's Preview:
This is the quintessential Western story: A stranger joins
settlers in need of help. He has a hidden, violence-filled
past, but is trying to put that behind him. When a greedy
landowner brings in thugs to run the settlers off the land,
Shane has a choice to make. I love the little boy in this film
(Brandon deWilde)
because he reminds me of, well, me.

George Stevens;
Paramount Pictures |
|
|
|
|
#11 Top |
|
 |
|
Once Upon a Time in the West
(1966),
Director: Sergio Leone, rated PG-13 for Western
violence
There were three men in her life. One to take her... one
to love her... and one to kill her.
 Starring: Claudia
Cardinale, Henry Fonda, Jason Robarbs, Charles Bronson, Woody
Strode, Cabriele Ferzetti, Jack Elam
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"He's whittlin' on a piece
of wood. I've got a feeling when he stops whittlin'...
Somethin's gonna happen." - Cheyenne
Why watch this?
This Leone Western is as good as they get.
Plot Summary:
Jill McBain, a former prostitute turned landowner, arrives in
the frontier town of Flagstone only to find her new husband and
his children murdered. A ruthless assassin, Frank, working for
railroad baron Morton, is responsible for the murders and has
framed the bandit Cheyenne. A mysterious man, known only as
Harmonica, also arrives seeking revenge against Frank. Jill,
Cheyenne, and Harmonica form an uneasy alliance as they attempt
to hold onto the valuable land that Morton wants for his
railroad.
Dad's Preview:
Sergio Leone directed many spaghetti Westerns, but this is by
far his magnum opus. There are many Western themes present, but
the line between good guys and bad guys is blurred enough to
really make it interesting. The film is large and epic, and
Charles Bronson is wonderful as the "harmonica player". The Morricone soundtrack is
top notch, even by his standards.

Euro Int'l Films,
Rafran Cinematografica, Finanzia San Marco;
Paramount Pictures |
|
|
|
|
#10 Top |
|
 |
|
The Ox-Bow Incident (1943),
Director: William A. Wellman, rated Approved
LYNCH LAW
RULES THE MOB!
 Starring: Henry
Fonda, Dana Andrews, Harry Morgan, Frank Conroy, Anthony Quinn,
William Eythe, Jane Darwell, Matt Briggs
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"You don't even care
whether you've got the right men or not. All you know is you've
lost something
and somebody's got to be punished." - Donald
Martin
Why watch this?
This is a twist on the old West's posse - what if they catch the
wrong people?
Plot Summary:
In a small Western town, news arrives that a local rancher has
been murdered and his cattle stolen. With the sheriff out of
town, a posse forms to track down the perpetrators. When the
posse finds three men with cattle bearing the rancher's brand, a
heated debate ensues about whether to administer immediate
justice or wait for the sheriff and a formal trial.
Dad's Preview:
The American Western film is a great vehicle for the morality tale. It's
easier to depict how people will act in a setting where many
laws had to be enforced by the citizens, not the government. In
this film a rancher has been murdered and a mob forms to bring
justice. They find
three men with cattle and assume these men are the murders. The mob,
led by the tyrannical, bigoted Major Tetley, sets to hang the men. This
is a great exercise in the evils of mob mentality and groupthink.

Lamar Trotti; 20th
Century Fox |
|
|
|
|
#9 Top |
|
 |
|
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
(1969),
Director: George Roy Hill, rated PG
You never
met a pair like Butch and The Kid.
 Starring: Paul
Newman, Robert Redford, Katharine Ross, Strother Martin, Jeff
Corey, Henry Jones, George Furth, Cloris Leachman,
Richard Kiel
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"It's
your great ideas that got us into this mess.
I never want to
hear another one of your great ideas. Ever!" -
Sundance Kid
Why watch this?
It's really fun to see Newman and Redford having such a good
time.
Plot Summary: Two
notorious outlaws, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, rob banks
and trains in the late 1800s American West. Facing relentless
pursuit by a skilled posse, they flee with Sundance's
girlfriend, Etta Place, to Bolivia seeking a fresh start.
However, their attempts to escape their past lead to a series of
humorous and action-packed events as they continue their
criminal ways.
Dad's Preview:
This film certainly stands out as different among
Westerns of its time. Newman and Redford portray the famous
real-life bank robbers, Butch and Sundance. The film's quip-filled dialog almost doesn't fit the
era, but I can let that slide, as it helps the
film flow. During the movie, we root for our anti-heroes to
escape the law, get across the Mexican border, and make it to Bolivia.
But even there, they still become wanted men. The lauded film won four Oscars.

Campanile
Productions, Newman-Foreman Company; 20th Century-Fox |
|
|
|
|
#8 Top |
|
 |
|
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962),
Director: John Ford, rated PG-13 for Western
violence
Two Great Stars Appear Together For the First Time!
 Starring: James
Stewart, John Wayne, Vera Miles, Lee Marvin, Edmond O’Brien,
Andy Devine, Woody Strode, Strother Martin, Lee Van Cleef
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"This is the West, sir.
When the legend becomes fact...print the legend." – Maxwell
Scott
Why watch this?
... finally! Two classic film titans, Wayne and Stewart, together on screen!
Plot Summary:
Senator Ransom Stoddard returns to the small frontier town of
Shinbone for the funeral of an old friend Tom Doniphon. When
asked by a newspaper reporter about his presence, Stoddard
recounts the story of his arrival in the lawless territory as a
young lawyer and his fateful confrontation with the notorious
outlaw, Liberty Valance. Stoddard's tale delves into the complex
relationship between himself, Tom, and the pursuit of law and
order in the developing West.
Dad's Preview:
This allegorical film chronicles the decline the Wild West and
the hard men who thrived in its chaos. The strength of the film
is its director, the legendary John Ford. This man knew Westerns
and he knew how to direct John Wayne. Lee Marvin was superbly
cast as the cruel,
sadistic title ruffian. Pilgrim, you're going to love this
complicated, black and white horse opera.

John Ford
Productions; Paramount Pictures |
|
|
|
|
#7 Top |
|
 |
|
The Outlaw Josey Wales
(1976),
Director: Clint Eastwood, rated PG
... an army of
one.
 Starring: Clint
Eastwood, Chief Dan George, Sondra Locke, Bill McKinney, John
Vernon, Sam Bottoms
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"You
gonna pull them pistols or just whistle Dixie?" - Josey
Wales
Why
watch this? Star/Director Eastwood hits his stride
with this memorable Western.
Plot Summary:
A Missouri farmer's family is murdered by pro-Union militants
during the Civil War. Driven by a desire for vengeance, he joins
a Confederate guerrilla band, becoming a feared gunfighter.
After the war, he refuses to surrender and becomes an outlaw
pursued by bounty hunters and soldiers. He must navigate the
treacherous landscape of the post-Civil War West, encountering
allies and enemies as he seeks to survive and find a new path
for his life.
Dad's Preview:
In a performance chock full of iconic quotes, Clint
Eastwood created one of the great Westerns, and characters, of
all time. Wales is a man driven by revenge, but also justice, as
he hunts the men responsible for murdering his wife and son. It
is set immediately after the Civil war when gangs of ex-Union
soldiers roamed the West using their power, and the lack of
valid law enforcement, to murder and
pillage. The scene where Wales parlays with Chief Ten Bears is
one of my all-time favorites.

The Malpaso
Company; Warner Bros. |
|
|
|
|
#6 Top |
|
 |
|
Open Range (2003),
Director: Kevin Costner, rated R for Western violence
No place to
run. No reason to hide.
 Starring: Robert
Duvall, Kevin Costner, Annette Benning, Michael Gambon, Michael
Jeter, Diego Luna
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"Men are gonna get killed
here today, Sue, and I'm gonna kill 'em." - Charley Waite
Why watch this? ...
the
respect-filled relationship between cowhands Costner and Duvall.
Plot Summary:
Boss Spearman and his cattle crew, as free-grazers, are driving
their herd across the vast prairies of the Old West. When they
encounter a town ruled by a corrupt rancher and sheriff, their
peaceful existence is threatened. Forced to defend their values
and way of life, Boss and his second-in-command, Charley Waite,
find themselves drawn into an inevitable confrontation.
Dad's Preview:
Costner (as actor and director) and Duvall deliver one of the
best Westerns ever made. And I mean EVER! This film has breath-taking scenery, great
action sequences (one of the best, and most realistic gun
battles ever filmed), and many of the classic Western elements.
That said, the film's true strength is its character-building. There
are numerous, small
interactions that acquaint us with Charley, Boss, Sue, and the
rest. Costner should have taken home at least one Oscar for
his efforts here.

Touchstone
Pictures, Cobalt Media Group, Beacon Comm., Tig Productions;
Buena Vista Pictures Dist. |
|
|
|
|
#5 Top |
|
 |
|
Unforgiven (1992),
Director: Clint Eastwood, rated R for language,
Western violence
It's a hell of
a thing, killing a man
 Starring: Clint
Eastwood, Gene Hackman, Morgan Freeman, Richard Harris, Jaimz
Woolvett, Saul Rubinek, Frances Fisher
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"It's a hell of a thing, killin' a man. You take away all he's got,
and all he's ever gonna have." - William Munny
Why watch this? This is Eastwood's
masterpiece, a testament to a lifetime in the film business.
Plot Summary: Set in
the late 1800s, this Western follows William Munny, a retired,
once-feared gunslinger turned struggling hog farmer. When news
of a bounty for the killing of two cowboys who disfigured a
prostitute reaches him, Munny, needing money for his children,
reluctantly takes on the job. He teams up with his old partner
Ned Logan and a young, aspiring gunfighter known as the
Schofield Kid to confront the harsh realities of violence and
the changing West, blurring the lines between hero and villain.
Dad's Preview:
This gem is the culmination two key factors: Eastwood's vast
experience and clout in directing, and a tonal shift in Westerns to be more realistic.
An aging widower (and ex-gunman) has no choice but to perform
one last dirty
job to get badly needed money to support his kids. However, when pushed too hard, his old ways resurface.
Eastwood and Freeman are superb, but Gene Hackman's performance,
as the notorious sheriff Little Bill, steals every scene. It's
brutal and real and worth your time.

Malpaso
Productions; Warner Bros. |
|
|
|
|
#4 Top |
|
 |
|
The Wild Bunch
(1969),
Director: Sam Peckinpah, rated R for language,
violence
Nine men who
came too late and stayed too long...
 Starring:
William Holden, Ernest Borgnine, Robert Ryan, Edmond O'Brien,
Jaime Sánchez, Ben Johnson, Warren Oates, Emilio Fernández,
Strother Martin, L.Q. Jones, Albert Dekker, Bo Hopkins, Alfonso
Arau, Dub Taylor
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★☆
- near perfect
"We're gonna stick
together, just like it used to be! When you side with a man, you
stay with him! And if you can't do that, you're like some
animal, you're finished! We're finished! All of us!" -
Pike Bishop
Why watch this?
Peckinpah's great ode to Western violence stands the test of
time.
Plot Summary:
Set in 1913, an aging group of outlaws attempt one last big
score during a time when the traditional American West is
fading. After a botched railroad office robbery, they flee to
Mexico with bounty hunters on their trail, led by a gang member.
In Mexico, they get involved with a rogue Mexican general while
trading guns and ammo.
Dad's Preview: Two
years after the shocking violence (well, not by today's
standards) in
Bonnie and
Clyde (1967), this film hit screens. Critics were split,
mostly due to the wanton violence and ruthless nature of the
lead characters. What everyone, then and now, can agree upon is
that the film is well-directed, the all-star cast's performances
are career-defining, and the cinematography, a slow-motion
ballet of savagery set in the angry Mexican landscape, is
breathtaking. William Holden deserved an Oscar for his portrayal
of Pike. These men depicted - killers, thieves, hired guns -
have no concept of a normal life. They are past their prime.
Yet, they live by the brutal outlaw code of the West: stick
together to the bitter, and in this case bloody, end.

Touchstone Films,
Silver Screen Partners II; Buena Vista Dist. Co.
|
|
|
|
|
#3 Top |
|
 |
|
High Noon (1952),
Director: Fred Zinnemann, rated PG
the story of a
man who was too proud to run!
 Starring: Gary
Cooper, Thomas Mitchell, Lloyd Bridges, Katy Jurado, Grace
Kelly, Otto Kruger, Lon Chaney Jr., Henry Morgan
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
"You risk your skin
catching killers and the juries turn them loose so they can come
back and shoot at you again.
If you're honest you're poor your
whole life and in the end you wind up dying all alone on some
dirty street." -
Martin
Why watch this?
Watching Cooper act is like butter melting on a piece of
toast.
Plot Summary:
On the day of his wedding and retirement, Marshal Will Kane
learns that Frank Miller, an outlaw he sent to prison, has been
released and is returning on the noon train for revenge. Despite
his new wife's urging to leave, Kane feels a duty to stay and
confront the threat, but finds the townspeople, including his
deputies and friends, unwilling to help him. As the clock ticks
towards the inevitable showdown, Kane must grapple with the
decision to face Miller and his gang alone or abandon the town
that has abandoned him.
Dad's Preview:
It had all the ear marks of a standard Western drama: a sheriff
has to stand against outlaws, backed by his deputies and
concerned citizens. Except that is not what happens. This
sheriff is forced to really stand alone. His friends and
deputies quit, one by one. Even his fiancé leaves him. Yet this
lawman, portrayed by the great Gary Cooper, knows he has to stay
- this is his job, and a man does his job. This simple plot
element makes this Western classic unique and
feel more real.

Stanley Kramer
Productions; United Artists |
|
|
|
|
#2 Top |
|
 |
|
Dances With Wolves (1990),
Director: Kevin Costner, rated PG-13 for frontier
violence
Lt. John Dunbar is about to discover the
frontier...within himself.
 Starring:
Kevin Costner, Mary McDonnell, Graham Greene, Rodney Grant,
Floyd Red Crow Westerman, Tantoo
Cardinal, Jimmy Herman
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
DML Top 50
#2 -
Dad's Full (Spoiler) Review
and Deep Dive of Dances With Wolves
"I've never known a people so
eager to laugh, so devoted to family, so dedicated to each other. And,
the only word that came to mind was harmony." - John Dunbar
Why watch this?
This "Western" finally depicts Native Peoples with accuracy.
Plot Summary: This
epic Western film, starring and directed by Kevin Costner, was
adapted from Michael Blake's novel of the same name. It tells
the story of a Union Army lieutenant who requests duty on the
American frontier and develops a profound connection with a
tribe of Sioux Indians. The film explores themes of cultural
exchange, prejudice, and the conflict between expanding American
civilization and Indigenous ways of life.
Dad's Preview:
For five years Costner established himself as a leading man
in such films as
Silverado
(1985) and
Bull Durham
(1988).
Dances changed all that, by proving that he was a also a serious
filmmaker. This beautiful work of frontier art strips
away many previous notions of the American
West as portrayed on film. A lone Northern soldier heads West.
There he encounters Native Americans, namely a Lakota Sioux tribe. He
learns that all the rumors about these people are false, and he
embraces the relationship. However, in America, it's never that
simple. The scenery is breath-taking, all set to an incredible
musical score. This Oscar-winner is a glorious epic to behold.

Tig
Productions, Majestic Films Int.; Orion Pictures |
|
|
|
|
#1 Top |
|
 |
|
The Searchers
(1956),
Director: John Ford, rated Approved
The Biggest,
Roughest, Toughest ...and Most Beautiful Picture Ever Made!
 Starring: John Wayne,
Jeffrey Hunter, Vera Miles, Ward Bond, Natalie Wood, John Qualen, Olive
Carey, Henry Brandon, Ken Curtis, Harry Carey Jr.
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★★★
- perfect
DML Top 50
#8 -
Dad's Full (Spoiler) Review
and Deep Dive of The Searchers
"Seems like he never
learns there's such a thing as a critter that'll just keep comin'
on. So we'll find 'em in the end,
I promise you. We'll find 'em.
Just as sure as the turnin' of the earth."
– Ethan Edwards,
referring to the Indians who kidnapped Debbie
Why watch this?
Basically to watch the greatest Western ever made.
Plot Summary:
Confederate veteran Ethan Edwards has returned to his brother's
Texas homestead only to find it raided by Comanches, his family
massacred, and his niece Debbie abducted. Fueled by a complex
mix of hatred and a desire for vengeance, Ethan embarks on a
years-long search with Debbie's adopted brother, and half-breed,
Martin.
Dad's Preview:
This is by far the most complex character in John Wayne's
long, storied career. Set in the stark, beautiful desert landscape of
Monument Valley, famous director John Ford masterfully delivers
this Western odyssey filled with danger, tragedy, and two lost
men - determined to rescue a kidnapped family relative, young
Debbie. After years of making
movies together, Ford knew
Wayne could create a compelling, conflicted character, and not just play
himself. Throw in our history's racism towards Native
Americans, and you've got a powerful film. The
final scene forever belongs to cinematic history. Wayne deserved
the Oscar for Best Actor, in my opinion.

C.V. Whitney
Pictures; Warner Bros. |
|
|
|
|