The Westerner (1940), Director: William Wyler, rated Approved

Roaring Prairie Fire. Desperate Fighting. Flaming Romance.

Film ClipStarring: Gary Cooper, Walter Brennan, Doris Davenport, Fred Stone, Forrest Tucker, Paul Hurst, Chill Wills, Lilian Bond, Dana Andrews, Charles Talton, Tom Tyler

DML Rating: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ - great

"When I was a kid, I had a pet rattlesnake. I was fond of it, but I wouldn't turn my back on it." - Cole Harden, to Judge Bean

Why watch this? Cooper and Brennan take center stage in this classic horse opera.

Plot Summary: A drifter named Cole Harden is brought before the corrupt, self-appointed "hanging judge" Roy Bean in Texas and narrowly escapes death by exploiting the judge's intense, personal obsession with famous singer Lily Langtry. Despite this uneasy introduction, the two men develop a strange friendship, which is tested as Harden sides with local homesteaders against the cattle ranchers and ruthless tactics favored by Bean.

  Dad's Preview: The two great early Western actors were John Wayne and Gary Cooper. Both always embodied the Western loner, a man of principals and honor who is not afraid to stand up to lawlessness. In those days, they would make six films a year so it's my job to ferret out the better entries. Here, a young, handsome wanderer, Cole Harden, finds himself at odds with the notorious Judge Roy Bean (who was a real judge in Val Verde County, Texas). The strength of this film, centered on a range war between cattlemen and fence-stringing homesteaders, is the tenuous friendship between the gruff Judge and the affable Hardin. You can sense where things are heading. There is action, romance and gunplay aplenty, however, all stands second to Walter Brennan's Oscar-winning performance as the eccentric Judge Roy Bean.  


Samuel Goldwyn Productions; United Artists

Back