The Proposition
(2005),
Director: James L. Brooks, rated R for language,
Western violence
Three
brothers: one must live; one must die; one must decide
 Starring: Guy
Pearce, Ray Winstone, Danny Huston, John Hurt, David Wenham,
Emily Watson, Richard Wilson, Noah Taylor, Jeremy Madrona
DML Rating:
★★★★★★★★☆☆
- great
"I was, in days gone
by, a believer. But, alas, I came to this beleaguered land and
the God in me
just evaporated. Let us change our toast, then, to
the God that has forgotten us."-
Jellon Lamb
Why watch this?
This uber-realistic film is stark, honest and
bare-bones wonderful.
Plot Summary:
In the harsh Australian outback of the 1880s, two outlaw
brothers are apprehended by a lawman determined to bring order
to the land. Faced with an impossible choice, the captured
outlaw must hunt down and kill his older brother, the true
leader of their gang, within nine days to save their younger
brother from hanging.
Dad's Preview:
This 1880's outback Western is brutally unromantic. There are no
heroics, no men who save the day. It's just kill or be killed
and good luck figuring out who is noble vs. devious. Everyone is
a little of both. Still, the film draws you in. So much so that
you have to see it through. I feel this is Guy Pearce's best performance on the big
screen. His portrayal of Charlie Burns is so raw and
uncomplicated. It reminded me of "the kid" from Cormac
McCarthy's likewise brutally violent book
Blood Meridian.

UK Film Council,
Surefire Films, Autonomous, Jackie O Prod.,
Pictures in
Paradise,
The Pacific Film and TV Comm., The Film
Consortium; Sony
Pictures Releasing |